Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., March 11, 2008 Adar2 5, 5768 | | Israel Time: 03:27 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

Last update - 10:25 01/12/2006 New research reveals Vatican criticism of Holocaust-era Pope By Amiram Barkat, Haaretz Correspondent New research reveals rare criticism from within the Vatican of Holocaust-era Pope Pius XII for his silence in the face of the destruction of European Jewry. Pius XII is controversial due to claims that he knew of the genocide as early as the early 1940s but did not act to stop it. In 1999, the Vatican appointed the International Catholic-Jewish Historical Commission to investigate the charges against Pius XII, but the panel disbanded after it was refused access to archival material. Advertisement Professor Dina Porat, who headed the Project for the Study of Anti-Semitism at Tel Aviv University, centered her research on criticism of Pius XII from the Papal Nuncio Angelo Giuseppe Roncalli, who fifteen years later became Pope John XXIII. According to Porat's research, in 1943, Roncalli, then the nuncio in Turkey, wrote to the Catholic president of Slovakia asking him to stop the deportation of Slovakian Jews to Auschwitz. He wrote the letter at the behest of Jewish Agency delegate Haim Barlas, with whom he had a close personal relationship. In 1944 Barlas received the "Auschwitz Protocols," detailed accounts by Rudolf Vrba and Alfred Wetzler, who had escaped the concentration camp in April of that year. Barlas sent the diaries directly to Roncalli, later writing in his memoirs that Roncalli was shocked and read them in tears. According to Barlas, after reading the eyewitness accounts, Roncalli told him he was filled with resentment towards his superiors, "whose power and influence are great, but who refrain from action and resourcefulness in extending concrete help." Roncalli told Barlas he would send the protocols to the Vatican immediately. This does not correspond with the official Vatican version, according to which Pope Pius XII received the protocols only in October of that year. Several days after Roncalli's conversation with Barlas, the Pope sent a letter to Hungarian Regent Horthy asking him to stop the "human suffering" in his country, without explicitly mentioning the Jews. Deportations to Auschwitz did stop shortly after that, but only after 400,000 Hungarian Jews were murdered at the death camp. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Bring down the house Knesset speaker calls for wrecking of yeshiva killer's family home. Frum and fabulous Beauty salons offer Haredi women a unique brand of modest glamour.   1.   Pope during holocaust 02:22  |  Usher Buchwalter 01/12/06   2.   Some Jews never let up on Pius XII`s alleged "silence" 03:43  |  hollingsworth 01/12/06   3.   Fear And Power 04:35  |  Tony Anthony 01/12/06   4.   If the Vatican has nothing to hide, open up the Vatican archives! 04:54  |  AV 01/12/06   5.   # 2. it is not so easy or simple as that. while it hurts, thats 05:33  |  ralph 01/12/06   6.   The Pope 06:01  |  Edithann 01/12/06   7.   So sue the world already. Who is speaking out 06:23  |  George 01/12/06   8.   nothing to hide 07:50  |  hollingsworth 01/12/06   9.   To Hollingsworth 09:56  |  Jacob 01/12/06   10.   VATICAN ON BOSNIA AND KOSOVO 11:03  |  indrajaya 01/12/06   11.   Einstein # 2 11:41  |  charles 01/12/06   12.   The villain of tomorrows history targets villains of yesteryear 13:16  |  Natallie Durson 01/12/06   13.   WORDS: HIND SIGHT IS 20/20 13:17  |  Dr David I. Gross 01/12/06   14.   # 2 Edithann, Does Kastners failing absolve the powerful Church? 13:33  |  Haham me Bat yam 01/12/06   15.   RE # 12 natallies Dursons smear of Rabbis! was it necessary???? 13:58  |  Haham me Bat yam 01/12/06   16.   Papal inactivity 14:47  |  Joe 01/12/06   17.   2 - Response 15:09  |  Bruriah Sarah 01/12/06   18.   He did not have much choice 15:11  |  Edith 01/12/06   19.   The Pope Made a Deal to save historic buildings, not jews 16:04  |  topanga 01/12/06   20.   But we can all see what motivates you, Natalie 16:19  |  Jacob Blues 01/12/06   21.   pope 16:26  |  taz 01/12/06   22.   18 Edith: I am a Catholic too 16:29  |  KUTW 01/12/06   23.   Nat Durson #12,,what motivates a bigot? 16:58  |  albert amato 01/12/06   24.   Good to learn from History but we need to act when it happens 17:04  |  omolll 01/12/06   25.   Hollingsworth 17:15  |  the Saint 01/12/06   26.   This Is Not New News 17:38  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/12/06   27.   Church and believers 17:45  |  Luca 01/12/06   28.   to #10 - no excuses 17:50  |  Luca 01/12/06   29.   KUTW 18:41  |  the Saint 01/12/06   30.   Hollingsworth abusing Albert Einstein 18:46  |  Jonathan S 01/12/06   31.   To Indrajaya, 10 19:05  |  Jozef 01/12/06   32.   The Jews of South Africa #19 20:24  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/12/06   33.   Edith And KUTW: I Am "Protestant" And Free Thought Is Wrong 20:26  |  Gerald 01/12/06   34.   Edith And KUTW: Words Mean Things 20:28  |  Philip 01/12/06   35.   the Saint #25 20:29  |  Hubal 01/12/06   36.   33. Gerald: And Free Thought Is Wrong 21:46  |  KUTW 01/12/06   37.   34. . Philip: Words Mean Things 21:53  |  KUTW 01/12/06   38.   29. the Saint: KUTW 22:05  |  KUTW 01/12/06   39.   why did Golda Meir praise Pius XII? 22:08  |  KUTW 01/12/06   40.   hollings worth#2" Some Jews never let up" 22:17  |  norman A. Blumberg 01/12/06   41.   The Rabbi Speaks! 22:20  |  W 01/12/06   42.   The Vatican/The Jews/Pope Pius XII 23:19  |  Ricardo Kolbe 01/12/06   43.   #34 Philip 23:21  |  Edith 01/12/06   44.   Daniel Jonah Goldhagen 23:25  |  Edith 01/12/06   45.   Hey "Saint" 23:33  |  hollingsworth 01/12/06   46.   "Want some names??" 23:35  |  hollingsworth 01/12/06   47.   To KUTW about the ill-fated Pope 23:35  |  Jonathan S 01/12/06   48.   Why does the vatican want to make him a saint then ?? 23:45  |  BIll. 01/12/06   49.   omoll 00:15  |  charles 02/12/06   50.   Kolbe 00:24  |  charles 02/12/06   51.   Catholics are good people 00:26  |  Tim 02/12/06   52.   What could he do? 00:37  |  David King 02/12/06   53.   KUTW: Man Is Evil 01:41  |  Gerald 02/12/06   54.   Edith #34 Philip 01:53  |  Philip 02/12/06   55.   PIUS XII 01:55  |  Mario Fiorito 02/12/06   56.   Care to offer a citation Natallie? 05:23  |  bbl 02/12/06   57.   Pius XII. 06:13  |  R 02/12/06   58.   47Jonathan S: About Pius XII 08:06  |  KUTW 02/12/06   59.   To bbl: 08:16  |  Natallie Durson 02/12/06   60.   53 Gerald 08:22  |  KUTW 02/12/06   61.   david gross and a statute of limitations 08:54  |  dubious 02/12/06   62.   catholism was gonna be #1 religion in europe 09:19  |  ahahha PHOENIX BIRD 02/12/06   63.   to all 11:18  |  Marcelo 02/12/06   64.   to Yaakov Sullivan #26 11:22  |  Colin Wright 02/12/06   65.   # 62, ahahha PHOENIX BIRD 12:48  |  indrajaya 02/12/06   66.   INDRAJAYA,AN UNFALTERING HYPOCRITE 15:48  |  gabriel 02/12/06   67.   To KUTW about the pope of silence 18:02  |  Jonathan S 02/12/06   68.   As an Mexican-American Catholic ....yeah flame the fires 19:34  |  N. 02/12/06   69.   Hitler and Catholicism 20:35  |  Joe 02/12/06   70.   David king 20:40  |  charles 02/12/06   71.   Vatican Knew 20:56  |  Jonathan Levy 02/12/06   72.   re #12 Natallie Durson 21:23  |  D Hirod 02/12/06   73.   Europ. Jewry/Vatican/Holocaust 21:44  |  Ricardo Kolbe 02/12/06   74.   Europ. Jewry/Cath. Germ. Sold./Holocaust 21:55  |  Ricardo Kolbe 02/12/06   75.   Mr Kolbe 22:18  |  charles 02/12/06   76.   #23 Alberto Amato re:Natalie D 23:46  |  eva 02/12/06   77.   @ 17 The very truth is allways very simple. 23:58  |  Karl 02/12/06   78.   @ W 00:34  |  Karl 03/12/06   79.   Palestinians are also Catholic 00:42  |  John 03/12/06   80.   Jerusalem holy to Christians 00:43  |  John 03/12/06   81.   #70 How many Catholics? 02:37  |  hollingsworth 03/12/06   82.   Christian Arabs 03:08  |  Joe 03/12/06   83.   Mexican American 04:19  |  sweis Melbourne 03/12/06   84.   after W #41 - a real Rabbi speaks 05:38  |  zeev 03/12/06   85.   hey mex watch those flames yourself 06:31  |  steve 03/12/06   86.   hollingsworth 06:35  |  steve 03/12/06   87.   the vatican critizises its own, about time! 06:40  |  steve 03/12/06   88.   #87- steve Vatcriticizes its own..... 09:10  |  tbora 03/12/06   89.   joe from baltimore 18:11  |  dubious 03/12/06   90.   steve 20:24  |  hollingsworth 03/12/06   91.   tbora 06:53  |  sweis Melbourne 04/12/06   92.   #12 Makes me sound like a racist 02:11  |  Natallie Durson 11/03/08

Today Online Abbas: Israel has agreed to a cease-fire with Hamas Responses: 409 Amos Oz: Left wing can return to power in next elections Responses: 147 Akiva Eldar: Israel knows the price it has to pay for security Responses: 74 AJC leader urges Israel to give 'Durban 2' meet a chance Responses: 99 Rosner's Domain Study: Boston's intermarried 'as observant' as Reform Jews Whose Jerusalem Is It, anyway? Poll: Should Abbas and Olmert continue their talks? An Israeli and a crocodile (WTR) Rosner's Mailbox: Stop focusing on Israel's favorability polls More Headlines 23:07 UN Chief, U.S. urge Israel to halt plans to build in W. Bank settlements 02:33 Abbas: Israel has agreed to cease-fire with Hamas 22:01 FM to U.S. officials: Hamas will not choose when to fire and when to regroup 03:01 Police inquiry focusing on response to yeshiva attack 02:11 Britain bans Likud's Moshe Feiglin from entering country 22:10 Knesset speaker calls for demolition of Jerusalem yeshiva terrorist's home 14:43 In show of modesty, Haredi women make up in private 01:19 J'lem official: Major quake could kill generation of schoolchildren 23:32 Greek Cyprus opposes Turkish Cypriot plan to open trade office in T.A. 01:40 Director, screenwriter guilds to boycott television awards ceremony 23:15 Sarkozy to Peres: France will always be at Israel's side Previous Editions Select Day 10 mar 09 mar 07 mar 06 mar 05 mar 04 mar 03 mar 02 mar 29 feb 28 feb 27 feb 26 feb

Special Offers Advertisement READY FOR PURIM? BUT - Who Will Guard The Hamentasch? Free the Palestinians from: Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy Long-term Israel programs MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants. NEW! Dan Boutique Jerusalem Hotel Hip Dan Hotel in Jerusalem. Attractive Introductory Rates 7589 rockets fired so far HELP US TO HELP THEM FREE JEWISH HISTORY COURSE Berel Wein's best selling lectures. 5000 Years in Five hours /CD/MP3 Marina Royale Herzelia Pituach Your Luxurious Suite While Staying in Israel Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved