Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., December 13, 2006 Kislev 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:54 (EST+6)
Haaretz israel news English
Search site 
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Prime Minister Ehud Olmert addressing the Israel Business Conference in Tel Aviv on Monday, ahead of a visit to Germany. (Reuters)
Last update - 02:02 13/12/2006
Gulf states call for sanctions on Israel for having nuclear weapons
By Yossi Verter, Haaretz Correspondent, Haaretz Staff and Agencies

Following Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's apparent public confirmation that Israel possesses nuclear weapons on Monday, an organization representing six Persian Gulf states called on the United States and the international community to "place sanctions on Israel for their nuclear program."

Gulf Cooperation Council Secretary-General Abdul Rahman ibn Hamad al-Attiyah, said Tuesday "the U.S. must not apply double standards since it calls for sanctions on countries that have nuclear programs that we have not ruled out are framework of nuclear weapons." According to al-Attiyah, the world must regard Olmert's statement as a global threat to peace and security

Earlier Tuesday, Olmert said that "Israel won't be the first country to introduce nuclear weapons into the Middle East."

Advertisement

Olmert repeated the comments three times during a joint press conference with German Chancellor Angela Merkel, a day after the seeming confirmation during an interview. Olmert also said that nothing he said during that interview violated the official Israeli position.

During the press conference, Merkel said that in her opinion the option of military intervention in Iran is not on the agenda. Merkel also said that Germany had tried to secure the release of the two Israeli soldiers kidnapped by Hezbollah.

Aides to the prime minister, seeking to quell a political storm over Olmert's remarks, said Tuesday that the prime minister had been misinterpreted and had not violated Israel's traditional policy of "nuclear ambiguity."

The statement, which provoked calls for Olmert's resignation, followed recent comments by newly appointed U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, who listed Israel among the nations near iran which possessing nuclear arms.

Olmert, who began an official visit to Germany Monday, told the German television news channel N24 in an interview that "we have never threatened any nation with annihilation. Iran, openly, explicitly and publicly threatens to wipe Israel off the map. Can you say that this is the same level, when they are aspiring to have nuclear weapons, as America, France, Israel, Russia?"

It is not clear whether this was a slip of the tongue on the part of Olmert or an intended statement. But the Prime Minister's Office said the statement was misinterpreted.

The prime minister "listed Israel among the list of responsible nations, and not the list of nations which have nuclear weapons," the Prime Minister's Office was quoted by Israel Radio as saying.

Reiterating Israel's traditional policy of "nuclear ambiguity," aides to the prime minister stressed that "The prime minister said that Israel will not be the first nation in the region to arm itself with nuclear weapons."

Olmert's comments raised a storm among political figures in Israel.

MK Yuval Steinitz (Likud) called on Olmert to resign following "a series of problematic slips of the tongue in matters of defense."

According to Steinitz, "the terrible statement made in Germany undermines 50 years of Israel's policy of ambiguity, and joins the irresponsible slips of the tongue such as the announcement regarding the fate of the abducted soldiers in Lebanon. A prime minister who is unable to control his statements on sensitive matters of security, must quit."

Meretz chairman, MK Yossi Beilin said that "the fantastic statement of the prime minister on the nuclear issue reflects the carelessness ... and raises serious doubts whether this is a person worthy of serving as prime minister."

MK Aryeh Eldad (National Union) said that if Olmert's statements reflect an intentional change in policy then he must release "an clear announcement to the free world, that if you do not stop Iran, we will stop it at any cost."

Olmert's spokesman, Miri Eisen, who accompanied the prime minister on a trip to Germany on Monday, said he did not mean to say that Israel possessed or aspired to acquire nuclear weapons.

"No he wasn't saying anything like that," she said.

Israeli Foreign Ministry spokesman Mark Regev said Olmert had meant to categorize the four nations as democracies to set them apart from Iran, and was not referring to their potential nuclear capabilities or aspirations.

Olmert's comments come a week after the incoming U.S. secretary of defense, Robert Gates, shocked observers when he said that Israel possessed nuclear arms, before a Congressional confirmation panel.

Meanwhile, German Chancellor Angela Merkel visited Olmert in his hotel in Berlin, last night for a meeting that was described as "private."

A private meeting room was set up at the InterContinental, where Olmert and his aides are staying, for the meeting. The two leaders at first met in private and were then joined by aides.

The meeting between the two was not on the official schedule of the visit, and aides were quick to point out that it reflected the warm and special ties between the two leaders.

Prior to his departure for Germany on Monday, Olmert said that Germany should curtail its commercial ties with Iran and that the interests of private businessmen in Germany should not influence German policy regarding Iran.

Germany will assume the rotating European Union presidency on January 1, 2007, and aides to Olmert say that his close ties with Merkel will avail Israel of a friendly interlocutor in matters having to do with the Palestinians.

Olmert and Merkel met officially Tuesday at the Chancellery in Berlin.

Prior to the meeting, Olmert addressed a ceremony commemorating the victims of the Holocaust at Grunewald Station's Platform 17 in Berlin.

"Woe are the weak and defenseless. Woe is he who refuses to believe the words of those who threaten to destroy him. Woe is the complacent man that fails to use his weapons to foil danger. Woe is he who entertains the delusion that he is beyond harm, and that is dependent upon the kindness of strangers," said Olmert in his address, adding that this is the main lesson of the Holocaust, and that "this is a lesson that Israel has learned and memorized."

Olmert will also meet the German President, Horst Kohler, Tuesday and Wednesday will leave Germany for Italy where he is scheduled to meet Prime Minister Romano Prodi and the Pope, Benedict XVI.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Comedy of errors
At Egypt's film festival, so much went wrong that no one bothered to critique the films.
Navigating at sea
An old nautical legend tells of a man who sailed from Haifa to Cyprus without a map.
  1.   IRAN OR ISRAEL? 20:02  |  Mosa 11/12/06
  2.   Mmmm? 20:18  |  Yosemite Sam 11/12/06
  3.   Oh Why can`t this loser keep his stupid mouth shut? 20:23  |  dave 11/12/06
  4.   When will Olmert learn to shut his mouth... 20:24  |  bat yam 11/12/06
  5.   cut ties with Iran 20:25  |  Mary 11/12/06
  6.   All states should cut off their economic ties to Iran, before it 20:31  |  Rita 11/12/06
  7.   Only Israel Would have the Chutzpah be so Unreasonable 20:46  |  John from Canada 11/12/06
  8.   A little squirt of a country like Israel.... 20:58  |  Clickfool 11/12/06
  9.   #7 you may want to get your facts straight. 21:03  |  Mike 11/12/06
  10.   #7 you may want to get your facts straight. 21:04  |  Mike 11/12/06
  11.   #7 you may want to get your facts straight. 21:04  |  Mike 11/12/06
  12.   And I thought, dear Clickfool, that the Jews controlled the world 21:07  |  Yair 11/12/06
  13.   The dog and the caravane 21:08  |  Fritz 11/12/06
  14.   nukes 21:12  |  Marc 11/12/06
  15.   To #1 Mosa and #8 Clickfool... 21:36  |  Leo 11/12/06
  16.   Say what? 21:36  |  Shinzenbi 11/12/06
  17.   stop Germany and Iran 21:37  |  Nazi Germany 11/12/06
  18.   Please 21:39  |  Barry 11/12/06
  19.   When will it end? 21:39  |  Anguillilio 11/12/06
  20.   Iran Nukes 21:39  |  Natalie D. 11/12/06
  21.   Can of worms 21:41  |  Benjamin Bilski 11/12/06
  22.   So What Israel Has Iran Cannot Have 21:55  |  Yaakov Sullivan 11/12/06
  23.   Germany to sell Iran autos that run only on fartsen 22:04  |  as seen from space 11/12/06
  24.   Ehud Olmert: 12 points 22:10  |  Jonathan S 11/12/06
  25.   nuclear Ambiguity 22:13  |  Avi Yerushalmi 11/12/06
  26.   #8 Clickfraud 22:14  |  Boris 11/12/06
  27.   Everyone know Israel has Nukes 22:14  |  Albert 11/12/06
  28.   To John from Canada 22:15  |  Leafs Boy 11/12/06
  29.   Iran or Israel 22:19  |  Lou 11/12/06
  30.   Word up, Bat Yam 22:23  |  Paul 11/12/06
  31.   From the United States on down to a 2-bit dictatorship 22:25  |  George 11/12/06
  32.   Say what? 22:26  |  Lou 11/12/06
  33.   Olmert is reckless and perhaps unstable 22:28  |  MB 11/12/06
  34.   To Leafs Boy: The Proof is in the Pudding 22:29  |  John from Canada 11/12/06
  35.   Olmert is the best comedian after Bush 22:30  |  Petteri 11/12/06
  36.   #7 John 22:33  |  viking 11/12/06
  37.   #7 John 22:35  |  viking 11/12/06
  38.   To Lou - Iran or Israel? 22:36  |  Mosa 11/12/06
  39.   Realism, anyone? 22:37  |  Spectator 11/12/06
  40.   I Don`t Know Who THIS Palestine Natallie Is But... 22:38  |  Yosemite Sam 11/12/06
  41.   #29 Lou 22:40  |  viking 11/12/06
  42.   nighbars like that! 22:41  |  voll tourist 11/12/06
  43.   Israel living in Denial 22:48  |  sandnigger 11/12/06
  44.   MR PM have you forgot Lebanon that you destoryed last July? 22:48  |  US person 11/12/06
  45.   The rope is getting tighter 22:48  |  Tim 11/12/06
  46.   To #3 Dave 22:50  |  MGB 11/12/06
  47.   What we did to be punished with these kind of PM`s slip ups 22:55  |  Joseph E . 11/12/06
  48.   Olmert CALLING on Germany to cut its vast economic ties with Iran 22:57  |  JustMe 11/12/06
  49.   Well, then...Baruch haba, Ehud 23:12  |  christoph 11/12/06
  50.   What chutzpah 23:13  |  Axel 11/12/06
  51.   Clickfool #8: British Antisemitism 23:18  |  Fuffy 11/12/06
  52.   Germany 23:21  |  Katja 11/12/06
  53.   # 28 Leafs Boy 23:29  |  Axel 11/12/06
  54.   #1 23:30  |  From the Moon 11/12/06
  55.   To Fritz: Enough is enough #13 23:30  |  Jonathan S 11/12/06
  56.   Olmert: Israel no threat 23:31  |  Doman 11/12/06
  57.   why Israel 23:36  |  From the Moon 11/12/06
  58.   #29 Leafs Boy 23:41  |  Realist 11/12/06
  59.   Let`s Face It 23:46  |  Abe 11/12/06
  60.   T0 # 28, Leafs boy 23:47  |  tom 11/12/06
  61.   Re: Anguillilio "When Will It End" 23:49  |  kooskoos 11/12/06
  62.   when will these idiots learn to shut up 23:51  |  zionist forever 11/12/06
  63.   Olmert everywhere...... 23:58  |  Esther 11/12/06
  64.   Sullivan, a little disingenuous and hypocritical, don`t you think 23:58  |  Jake 11/12/06
  65.   John from Canada, Israel will keep up the flaccid rhetoric 00:01  |  Jake 12/12/06
  66.   Jeez, How Much More of This Jackass Can Israelies Stomach? 00:07  |  Tod Zuckerman 12/12/06
  67.   The charade is over 00:34  |  Jonathan S 12/12/06
  68.   Nuke Jerusalem 01:01  |  Gstar 12/12/06
  69.   Israel is so wierd . . . 01:03  |  revoltop 12/12/06
  70.   What Iran should give to Israel 01:03  |  Esau Sullivan 12/12/06
  71.   @ 7 John wrote.... 01:05  |  Karl 12/12/06
  72.   #29 OH REALLY 01:06  |  ballistic 12/12/06
  73.   Germany need to stop sale of subs! 01:13  |  Jens 12/12/06
  74.   Iran`s wonderful human rights record 01:13  |  Seymour 12/12/06
  75.   to yaakov,no,iran cant have nukes,are you stupid or something 01:19  |  terrornator 12/12/06
  76.   #9 Mike, a little exercise for you.... 01:20  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  77.   #15 Leo, laying into Iran 01:28  |  Johnboy 12/12/06
  78.   # 1. 01:34  |  tom 12/12/06
  79.   # 29. Lou 01:36  |  tom 12/12/06
  80.   where did it all go so wrong in Israel 01:42  |  zionist forever 12/12/06
  81.   Who interduced nukes to the ME? 01:53  |  Raed 12/12/06
  82.   The Bid Lie Uncovered 01:58  |  chet 12/12/06
  83.   Olmert the Idiot Has Justified Iran`s Need for a Nuclear Deterent 02:19  |  Mr. Knowitall 12/12/06
  84.   Correction for John from Canada 02:44  |  Native Son 12/12/06