Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., October 16, 2007 , | | Israel Time: 05:07 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Books Travel
The USS Liberty. (AP Archives)
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 14:04 04/10/2007
Israeli communications said to prove IAF knew Liberty was U.S. ship
By Yossi Melman, Haaretz Correspondent

The Israel Air Force warplanes and Israel Navy warships that attacked the USS Liberty on June 8, 1967, at the height of the Six-Day War, were aware that the vessel was an American spy ship, according to new testimony published Thursday in the Chicago Tribune.

The report stated that the U.S. National Security Agency - to which the intelligence gathering ship belonged - was able to intercept IAF communications according to which, at some stage, the pilots identified the ship as American but were nonetheless instructed to push ahead with the attack.

According to the report, some of the transcripts and intelligence information have disappeared, while the rest can be found in U.S. government archives.
Advertisement
Oliver Kirby, the NSA's deputy director for operations at the time of the Liberty attack, is quoted by the Tribune as confirming the existence of the transcripts, saying he personally read them.

"They said, 'We've got him in the zero,'" Kirby was quoted as saying, "whatever that meant - I guess the sights or something. And then one of them said, 'Can you see the flag?' They said 'Yes, it's U.S, it's U.S.' They said it several times, so there wasn't any doubt in anybody's mind that they knew it."

Kirby told the newspaper that the transcripts were "something that's bothered me all my life. I'm willing to swear on a stack of Bibles that we knew they knew."

The report also states that then U.S. defense secretary Robert McNamara ordered jets that had been dispatched to assist the Liberty turned around.

The Tribune quotes J.Q. "Tony" Hart, then a chief petty officer assigned to a U.S. Navy relay station in Morocco that handled communications between Washington and the 6th Fleet, as saying that he listened in as McNamara said, "President [Lyndon] Johnson is not going to go to war or embarrass an American ally over a few sailors."

McNamara, who is now 91, told the Tribune he has "absolutely no recollection of what I did that day," except that "I have a memory that I didn't know at the time what was going on."

Foreign Ministry Spokesman Mark Regev told the Tribune that the attack on the Liberty was "a tragic and terrible accident, a case of mistaken identity, for which Israel has officially apologized."

The USS Liberty was came under attack, first by IAF jets and then some 15 minutes later by Israel Navy warships, while patrolling off the shores of El-Arish in the Sinai Peninsula. 34 American sailors perished in the attack, 26 of them in the naval assault
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Part of Jerusalem?
PM Olmert questions whether Arab neighborhoods should be defined as part of the capital.
Who is a Jew?
Israel's draft constitution states that 'every Jew is entitled to immigrate to Israel.'
  1.   AnyLiberty Stories are very good for US Right wing ISRAEL haters 12:35  |  Alan 04/10/07
  2.   Israel new..friendly Fire.. 12:40  |  Ali 04/10/07
  3.   Israels first impulse? Lie every time. As with Pollard 12:40  |  Natallie Durson 04/10/07
  4.   US is a slave of Israel 13:01  |  Yossi 04/10/07
  5.   Breakthrough !!! 13:12  |  Genesis 04/10/07
  6.   NO CHANCE OF US PUNISHING ISRAEL 13:24  |  TrippleJump 04/10/07
  7.   US knew TOO 13:25  |  opinion 04/10/07
  8.   Time for Justice for US sailors murdered in the attack 13:28  |  Chris 04/10/07
  9.   So what ? 13:29  |  Igor 04/10/07
  10.   Another elders of zion? 13:31  |  Gene 04/10/07
  11.   Chris,boyo,US wasn`t helping Israel in 67,on the contrary 13:44  |  Absolute Sweden 04/10/07
  12.   #6 - there is always a chance. they will pay eventually. 13:45  |  Genesis 04/10/07
  13.   #1-so maybe we should hide it, just because it is true? 13:46  |  Genesis 04/10/07
  14.   #10 - Gene - the world will find out what really happened. 13:47  |  Genesis 04/10/07
  15.   Some People Still Swear They Saw Aliens At Roswell 13:51  |  Yosemite 04/10/07
  16.   Look at the picture right after the attack 13:55  |  Gene 04/10/07
  17.   Yossi is an arab posing as a jew on this site 13:56  |  Joseph 04/10/07
  18.   Chris 14:02  |  Joseph 04/10/07
  19.   Total BS 14:04  |  HonestAbe 04/10/07
  20.   Lying - it`s what Israel does best 14:04  |  Clickfool 04/10/07
  21.   Ignoring the facts won`t make them go away, Gene 14:12  |  Gray 04/10/07
  22.   US Caused Massive Casualties in Yom Kippur War 14:14  |  ralphsrant1 04/10/07
  23.   This is NO PROOF! 14:14  |  even 04/10/07
  24.   Very Israeli...attack the defenseless 14:18  |  Tim 04/10/07
  25.   Israeli Doctrine 14:23  |  Walid 04/10/07
  26.   Gene and dishonesty 14:25  |  Truths 04/10/07
  27.   Guilty conscience 14:27  |  Outraged Jew 04/10/07
  28.   Link to the Tribune`s story 14:28  |  Gray 04/10/07
  29.   Igor and so what 14:28  |  Edward 04/10/07
  30.   tell the truth about Rachel Corrie, too 14:29  |  ted 04/10/07
  31.   to Gene 14:30  |  Vince 04/10/07
  32.   CIA HASN`T BEEN FOOLINGT AROUND WITGH IDF SINCE. 14:33  |  Robert 04/10/07
  33.   Nice Going Haaretz 14:33  |  Steve from Raleigh 04/10/07
  34.   England, Japan, Germany, Canada, Mexico.... 14:34  |  Michael 04/10/07
  35.   For Gene # 10 14:38  |  Clickfool 04/10/07
  36.   Big Deal 14:44  |  Barry 04/10/07
  37.   to Natallie Durson#3 14:44  |  Ilya 04/10/07
  38.   Who is covering up what? 14:51  |  Adam 04/10/07
  39.   Gene (#10), I hope you don`t believe the "Elders" fabrication 14:53  |  Ron 04/10/07
  40.   #4 YOSSI 15:00  |  mich 04/10/07
  41.   respect for israel 15:04  |  respect 04/10/07
  42.   Liberty 15:12  |  charles 04/10/07
  43.   governments lie 15:17  |  realism 04/10/07
  44.   This story is misleading 15:17  |  Netanel 04/10/07
  45.   the anti israel myths persist despite the facts 15:18  |  victor hardman 04/10/07
  46.   What about 911? 15:20  |  Espart 04/10/07
  47.   So the Israeli pilots were speaking English to each other? 15:20  |  Amnon 04/10/07
  48.   Pat Tillman 15:20  |  Richard 04/10/07
  49.   Egyptian ship with US flag 15:21  |  Eduard 04/10/07
  50.   Michael 15:23  |  Walid 04/10/07
  51.   I doubt this is true 15:24  |  Ron 04/10/07
  52.   So what? 15:26  |  Fred Michaelsberg 04/10/07
  53.   Here we go again... 15:28  |  Joshua 04/10/07
  54.   #13 Ted: Corrie got what she deserved. 15:29  |  Fred Michaelsberg 04/10/07
  55.   Natalie on the banwagon 15:31  |  Ron 04/10/07
  56.   Intriguing story.... 15:31  |  Avrum 04/10/07
  57.   Liberty, Amira, Gideon. Always count on Ha`aretz 15:33  |  abu afak 04/10/07
  58.   Poor Kirby..we know what follows 15:37  |  B 04/10/07
  59.   ted loves lattes 15:37  |  peter 04/10/07
  60.   # 8 chris 15:40  |  mike 04/10/07
  61.   Case Closed? 15:41  |  Dan 04/10/07
  62.   Pilots were speaking Hebrew, NSA translated 15:43  |  Gray 04/10/07
  63.   You don`t sink ships without authentication! Period. 15:49  |  Gray 04/10/07
  64.   Rehashing the case is still worth it. 15:51  |  Seth Halpern 04/10/07
  65.   Rehashing the case is still worth it. 15:51  |  Seth Halpern 04/10/07
  66.   To all on #10 16:05  |  Gene 04/10/07
  67.   Finally, a congressional inquiry? 16:10  |  Klas 04/10/07
  68.   Order of events not made clear 16:11  |  Jake 04/10/07
  69.   Tim from Toronto; no YOU lie, lie, lie 16:17  |  Jake 04/10/07
  70.   Steve from Raleigh is correct; Haaretz is rehashing anecdotes 16:23  |  Jake 04/10/07
  71.   Nobody with half a brain 16:25  |  Axel 04/10/07
  72.   The USS Liberty 16:29  |  Dave 04/10/07
  73.   # 39 eduard 16:30  |  Axel 04/10/07
  74.   To Fred Michaelsberg 16:32  |  Jake 04/10/07
  75.   Why would they wait 40 years to release evidence? 16:34  |  Thinker 04/10/07
  76.   Liberties fate 16:35  |  Dan 04/10/07
  77.   heady days 16:36  |  Sabra 04/10/07
  78.   natalie Durson # 3 16:38  |  Sabra 04/10/07
  79.   US Played Both Sides and Got Caught 16:41  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  80.   US Played Both Sides and Got Caught #2 16:42  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  81.   US Played Both Sides and Got Caught #3 16:42  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  82.   Monday Morning Quarterbacks ............ 16:42  |  Dave from Chicago 04/10/07
  83.   In another 30 years 16:43  |  Sabra 04/10/07
  84.   Too Scared Israelis To Read This Message? 16:44  |  Johnny Johnston 04/10/07
  85.   I think Israel is telling the truth 16:47  |  Jake 04/10/07
  86.   The closest thing to truth: 16:53  |  Axel 04/10/07
  87.   The spy ship called Liberty 16:55  |  Alex 04/10/07
  88.   US Never Supported Israel Prior to 1967 16:56  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  89.   #43 Edward 17:00  |  Boycott 04/10/07
  90.   #45 Ron 17:02  |  Boycott 04/10/07
  91.   To Yossi ! Liberty was an accident 17:02  |  Edmond Danijean 04/10/07
  92.   John Loftus` Book "The Secret War Against the Jews" 17:04  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  93.   A Case of Mistaken Identity 17:04  |  Juniper 04/10/07
  94.   #16 Say Ralsphrant1 17:04  |  ballistic 04/10/07
  95.   # 77 sabra 17:07  |  Axel 04/10/07
  96.   #46 So what Fred M 17:08  |  ballistic 04/10/07
  97.   U.S.S.Liberty 17:10  |  Mechooel 04/10/07
  98.   Compensation? 17:10  |  American 04/10/07
  99.   # 3 Fatmah-the profesional lier... 17:11  |  Misha 04/10/07
  100.   No Prying Eyes 17:11  |  Walid 04/10/07
  101.   Americans who are more loyal to Israel 17:12  |  Boycott 04/10/07
  102.   Loyal Ally? Not Back Then BOYCOTT 17:16  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  103.   PEOPLE THE US NEVER SUPPORTED ISRAEL PRIOR TO 1967 17:19  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  104.   remember the reuben James?? 17:22  |  ROB OF MELBOURNE AUS 04/10/07
  105.   Legitimate self-defence 17:23  |  Jonathan S 04/10/07
  106.   Re: A Case of Mistaken Identity 17:24  |  utd 04/10/07
  107.   Liberty 17:25  |  Dave 04/10/07
  108.   A story that will not die 17:26  |  Mark Lincoln 04/10/07
  109.   # 93 Juniper 17:26  |  Axel 04/10/07
  110.   all gov`t lie - look at bush & etc 17:38  |  who cares 04/10/07
  111.   # 68 jake 17:41  |  Axel 04/10/07
  112.   USS Liberty crew are right 17:41  |  Janice 04/10/07
  113.   By ways of Deception 17:45  |  Bandar Michaels 04/10/07
  114.   #18 Joseph 17:46  |  Janice 04/10/07
  115.   How it Happened 17:49  |  Walid 04/10/07
  116.   American Flag 18:00  |  Shmuelshachor 04/10/07
  117.   Gary #64- of course they translated 18:05  |  Mark Lincoln 04/10/07
  118.   Some of the Chicago Tribune`s sources are very dubious 18:06  |  Jake 04/10/07
  119.   #112the worst friendly fire incident ever by the usa 18:11  |  victor hardman 04/10/07
  120.   Wow! 18:15  |  Basho 04/10/07
  121.   GZLives- comments 18:17  |  michael N 04/10/07
  122.   Why would israel attack an American ship? 18:18  |  AlexK 04/10/07
  123.   Americans deserved it! 18:19  |  El_Justiciero 04/10/07
  124.   more on what happened 18:24  |  Walid 04/10/07
  125.   Another conspiracy theory 18:25  |  B 04/10/07
  126.   Mark Lincoln, circular logic 18:27  |  Jake 04/10/07
  127.   to "admiral wallid" on #115 18:29  |  Shmuelshachor 04/10/07
  128.   Bandar Michaels 18:29  |  Walid 04/10/07
  129.   Walid spreading those lies .... 18:31  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  130.   Right back at ya .... BOYCOTT 18:33  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  131.   Another Tragic Mistake 18:35  |  J Olson 04/10/07
  132.   Lincoln, you know nothing about it 18:41  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  133.   Interesting how the Liberty issue keeps coming up 18:42  |  BradL 04/10/07
  134.   #102 GZlives 18:42  |  Boycott 04/10/07
  135.   Janice makes my point about ARAB SPIN 18:47  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  136.   Yes Israel sank a US SPY SHIP .... talk to LBJ about it 18:48  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  137.   Chris #8 18:49  |  jjvanka 04/10/07
  138.   Incomprehensible article 18:50  |  James 04/10/07
  139.   Who Sank The Israeli sub the DAKAR? 18:52  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  140.   How is spying treated as friendly? 18:53  |  Paul 04/10/07
  141.   Chicago Tribune article fails at key locations (i) 18:54  |  Jake 04/10/07
  142.   Dude! Spying is an act of war#8! 18:56  |  paul 04/10/07
  143.   Not a secret... Read 18:56  |  nm 04/10/07
  144.   That ship 18:57  |  Paul 04/10/07
  145.   THIS WAS THE JEWISH 9/11... WITH NO CONSEQUENCES 18:58  |  Arthur 04/10/07
  146.   Has Israel EVER done anything wrong???? 18:58  |  Ben 04/10/07
  147.   Liberty 19:00  |  Neal 04/10/07
  148.   LIBERTY SHIP 19:02  |  GOLDSILVER 04/10/07
  149.   Another blood libel. 19:04  |  Ariel 04/10/07
  150.   #32, Robert... 19:11  |  Silvienne 04/10/07
  151.   Israeli Testimonial 19:11  |  Walid 04/10/07
  152.   Watch the racists run 19:12  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 04/10/07
  153.   BEN JABO, please read this.... 19:13  |  silvienne 04/10/07
  154.   Chicago Tribune article fails at key locations (ii) 19:13  |  Jake 04/10/07
  155.   LBJ...LBJ...how many kids did you kill today? 19:15  |  Philip 04/10/07
  156.   Bandar Michaels` incredible lies 19:25  |  Jake 04/10/07
  157.   Arthur, be realistic 19:30  |  Netanel 04/10/07
  158.   GZLives 19:31  |  Walid 04/10/07
  159.   In a Time of War 19:35  |  Alan 04/10/07
  160.   Irrelevant blather. What matters is Liberty`s classified orders.. 19:37  |  Dr. L. Brnd 04/10/07
  161.   James 19:37  |  Walid 04/10/07
  162.   #49Eduard, The American Patriot, who needs enemy. 19:39  |  FRED 04/10/07
  163.   Time for America to cut Israel off 19:41  |  Mr. Knowitall 04/10/07
  164.   # 140 Paul 19:41  |  American in NY 04/10/07
  165.   #1 19:45  |  paul 04/10/07
  166.   OK, Conspiracy Theorists 19:53  |  Diane 04/10/07
  167.   The logical conclusion 19:53  |  natan 04/10/07
  168.   GZLives on Dakar 19:55  |  Walid 04/10/07
  169.   The Idiot Paul # 144 19:59  |  American in NY 04/10/07
  170.   Walid typical Arab reverse spin ... all BS 20:05  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  171.   GZ lives - can we see the photos???? 20:05  |  Janice 04/10/07
  172.   to Tim#24 Dudley George shooting 20:06  |  Ilya 04/10/07
  173.   Walid ... Gabriel Bron = Mahmoud, or Abdullah 20:09  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  174.   Goldsilver here is your answer 20:11  |  Janice 04/10/07
  175.   #158 Walid 20:12  |  yossi 04/10/07
  176.   Netanel # 157 20:12  |  American in NY 04/10/07
  177.   Idiotic term: Spying 20:15  |  Axel 04/10/07
  178.   ron 51 20:19  |  realism 04/10/07
  179.   # 152 Margie 20:20  |  Axel 04/10/07
  180.   dave 72 20:22  |  realism 04/10/07
  181.   Common Sense(1) 20:23  |  Moshe 04/10/07
  182.   Philip, listen to yourself 20:23  |  Jake 04/10/07
  183.   Ariel 20:24  |  Walid 04/10/07
  184.   # 11 absolute Sweden 20:28  |  Realistic Arab 04/10/07
  185.   where in transcript does it say Israel knew it was a US ship? 20:29  |  Observer 04/10/07
  186.   157 netanel (and the rest of the gang) 20:32  |  Axel 04/10/07
  187.   Its normal 20:39  |  Danite 04/10/07
  188.   What ally? 20:42  |  Yonatan 04/10/07
  189.   Chicago Tribune article regurgitates lies, big time 20:45  |  Jake 04/10/07
  190.   Common Sense(2) 20:47  |  Moshe 04/10/07
  191.   Paul - I agree that a spy is the worst...hence Pollard should rot 20:48  |  American 04/10/07
  192.   #121 Michael N - Sherman tanks - really! 20:50  |  Yonatan 04/10/07
  193.   Ariel - If the jews killed the americans then the jews should 20:51  |  Ariel Settlement? 04/10/07
  194.   Israeli Lobby Control Again? 20:51  |  Walid 04/10/07
  195.   People..Israel and Israelis SPY ALL THE TIME! 20:52  |  Make this shoe guy 04/10/07
  196.   Gag Orders About Incident 20:54  |  Walid 04/10/07
  197.   A tragic error, and perhaps also error in translation 20:54  |  Tosefta 04/10/07
  198.   murder of american sailors 20:55  |  charles 04/10/07
  199.   With friends like this who needs enemies 20:57  |  Cynic #2 04/10/07
  200.   #2 20:58  |  Tim 04/10/07
  201.   Lying Israelis 21:00  |  World Citizen 04/10/07
  202.   #150-Silvienne 21:02  |  Robert 04/10/07
  203.   Israeli Torpedo Boats Attack 21:02  |  Walid 04/10/07
  204.   #19.Honest Abe,When will you be doing Aliyah? 21:04  |  HONEST AMERICAN 04/10/07
  205.   Danite 21:07  |  Walid 04/10/07
  206.   Just another thorn on Israel`s side.... 21:09  |  Dolly 04/10/07
  207.   #53 Joshua, Common man,Loyalty to your country? 21:09  |  Billy Boy 04/10/07
  208.   Doesn`t matter IAF killed stupid US Navy men 21:11  |  American in Paris 04/10/07
  209.   US Covering up 21:13  |  Walid 04/10/07
  210.   Walid loves this stuff 21:20  |  danite 04/10/07
  211.   Why the Attack on the Liberty? 21:23  |  Walid 04/10/07
  212.   Walid 21:23  |  Danite 04/10/07
  213.   There is always chaos in war 21:26  |  Rod Davies 04/10/07
  214.   DEATH BY FRIENDLY FIRE 21:27  |  DANIEL 04/10/07
  215.   #146 21:27  |  Moshe 04/10/07
  216.   #17 arab posing as jew 21:28  |  Warren 04/10/07
  217.   tell the truth about Rachel Corrie, too??? 21:31  |  Rod Davies 04/10/07
  218.   Dave from Chicago #82 21:36  |  TonyL 04/10/07
  219.   Pay-bacxk time for the Mohammed el Drur Story 21:38  |  Natasha 04/10/07
  220.   To Rick , #172, lying through the teeth 21:38  |  Jake 04/10/07
  221.   So many lies.... 21:44  |  Dana 04/10/07
  222.   # 196 tosefta the fairy tale teller 21:44  |  Axel 04/10/07
  223.   Tim #99 Unfriendly fire. 21:45  |  American in NY 04/10/07
  224.   Who is a terrorist? 21:46  |  Abe 04/10/07
  225.   to #181.......Jake 21:47  |  Philip 04/10/07
  226.   This is a very old story abt. the Liberty..... 21:53  |  Dagma 04/10/07
  227.   Liberty Betraying Israelis 21:54  |  Benjamin 04/10/07
  228.   Bravo Tosefta #196 !!!! 22:00  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/10/07
  229.   To all the hypocrites crying crocodile tears over US sailors 22:01  |  Jake 04/10/07
  230.   Sabra # 77 very heady days, in fact the must have been high fac 22:01  |  American in NY 04/10/07
  231.   THat is not the surprising part 22:03  |  Rami 04/10/07
  232.   one day we will find that Israel was behind 9/11 22:05  |  Jose 04/10/07
  233.   to "amerika" the pinhead from tn on #146 22:06  |  Shmuelshachor 04/10/07
  234.   Tosefta - The magnitude of error 22:16  |  Mark Lincoln 04/10/07
  235.   liberty, sabra, nuclear israel 200 bomb, aparthied 22:16  |  Adnan 04/10/07
  236.   USS LIBERTY 22:17  |  Miriam 04/10/07
  237.   Innocent until proved guilty not for Israelis 22:18  |  Israeli 04/10/07
  238.   To realism, #179 22:19  |  Dave 04/10/07
  239.   to Walid#202 22:20  |  Ilya 04/10/07
  240.   Axel 22:21  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 04/10/07
  241.   Walid - true 22:23  |  Mark Lincoln 04/10/07
  242.   American in Paris 22:25  |  charles 04/10/07
  243.   GZLives 22:25  |  Walid 04/10/07
  244.   NO FRIENDLY FIRE FOLKS WAKE UP! 22:26  |  Steve 04/10/07
  245.   Tosefta 196 22:26  |  Chas. 04/10/07
  246.   To Jose, more than 400 Jews died on 9/11 22:29  |  Jake 04/10/07
  247.   # 225 shmuel 22:29  |  Axel 04/10/07
  248.   PUTRID NONSENSE 22:31  |  JOJO 04/10/07
  249.   to Axel#185 22:32  |  Ilya 04/10/07
  250.   American in NY, you forgot one minor detail 22:34  |  Jake 04/10/07
  251.   Jose in LA - 9/11 22:34  |  Netanel 04/10/07
  252.   to Axel#178 22:38  |  Ilya 04/10/07
  253.   To Dana, joke is on you 22:40  |  Jake 04/10/07
  254.   My Awakening (My Masterpiece!) 22:41  |  Hanoi das Schwein! 04/10/07
  255.   Steve, RE "napalmed the deck" 22:44  |  Jake 04/10/07
  256.   Pathetic Walid ... Gabriel Bron "reporter" BULLSH*T 22:46  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  257.   The fascinating thing is 22:46  |  Axel 04/10/07
  258.   NO FRIENDLY FIRE FOLKS - Thats right THEY WERE SPYING 22:49  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  259.   Israeli - no attempt ever made to 22:49  |  Mark Lincoln 04/10/07
  260.   Adnan .. no cartoons to riot about today? 22:50  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  261.   I see the Zionist hasbara machine... 22:51  |  Veritas 04/10/07
  262.   # 232 Israeli 22:52  |  Axel 04/10/07
  263.   MIRIAM ... IAF Sank a spy ship ... any problems with that? 22:53  |  GZLives 04/10/07
  264.   Mark Lincoln 22:54  |  Walid 04/10/07
  265.   # 237 margie 22:59  |  Axel 04/10/07
  266.   It`s simple, folks... 23:00  |  Veritas 04/10/07
  267.   It was during a war, dummies 23:05  |  Dave from Chicago 04/10/07
  268.   # 238 mark lincoln 23:07  |  Axel 04/10/07
  269.   There is nothing to be ashamed for 23:10  |  Jonathan S 04/10/07
  270.   It was during a war, dummies continued..... 23:12  |  Dave from Chicago 04/10/07
  271.   JOJO 23:13  |  Walid 04/10/07
  272.   157, netanel says 23:13  |  Thomas 04/10/07
  273.   to GZLives #259, you are right....and wrong 23:22  |  Dave from Chicago 04/10/07
  274.   Why all this hatred against the West? 23:22  |  Rodolfo 04/10/07
  275.   Ilya 23:27  |  Walid 04/10/07
  276.   # 255 mark 23:27  |  Axel 04/10/07
  277.   Walid 23:29  |  danite 04/10/07
  278.   pretty simple story, really... 23:31  |  wildman 04/10/07
  279.   Veritas, change your name to Mentiras 23:32  |  Jake 04/10/07
  280.   # 263 dave 23:32  |  Axel 04/10/07
  281.   l brnd 23:34  |  realism 04/10/07
  282.   GZlives - still waiting 23:34  |  Janice 04/10/07
  283.   USS LIBERTY 23:34  |  DAN 04/10/07
  284.   pretty simple story, really... 23:35  |  wildman 04/10/07
  285.   #211.. I agree with you Daniel 23:38  |  maoriboy 04/10/07
  286.   Walid, you are blowing hot air 23:39  |  Jake 04/10/07
  287.   Victor Hardman - soft upstairs? 23:41  |  Wiktor 04/10/07
  288.   To Thomas from Vienna 23:42  |  Jake 04/10/07
  289.   Walid Shame Shame! 23:47  |  Yosemite 04/10/07
  290.   At 91, now he remembers 23:47  |  Efox 04/10/07
  291.   #193 Yonathan- what`s your point? 23:49  |  michael N 04/10/07
  292.   Danite 23:49  |  Walid 04/10/07
  293.   Translating Mark Regev`s `accident`. 23:51  |  Maureen Ann 04/10/07
  294.   USS Liberty 23:55  |  Tim 04/10/07
  295.   Walid: where is your info from? 23:58  |  Zvi 04/10/07
  296.   What could Israel gain? 00:00  |  Axel 05/10/07
  297.   To #274, Dave from Chicago, a voice of sanity 00:00  |  Jake 05/10/07
  298.   all idiots post here!! 00:02  |  sniper 05/10/07
  299.   Axel, I am well aware 00:09  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  300.   Danite #278, stick with weapon superiority 00:10  |  Palestinian Prince 05/10/07
  301.   Jake, #251, You forgot, 00:14  |  American in NY 05/10/07
  302.   Pin-heads to the left, and pin-heads to the right 00:16  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  303.   Attn: All you anti-Semitic crap 00:20  |  Murray of Montreal 05/10/07
  304.   US sent ship 2 spy is GUILTY 00:22  |  sam 05/10/07
  305.   They knew we were American 00:22  |  USS Liberty survivor 05/10/07
  306.   What is obvious but unsatisfactory to the fanatics 00:23  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  307.   Jake, # 254 You ignorant idiot. U are the Joke 00:23  |  American in NY 05/10/07
  308.   Dave from Chicago #271 00:34  |  American in NY 05/10/07
  309.   ofcourse they did,but why 00:36  |  manochka 05/10/07
  310.   GZLives correct, US was not ally of Israel, also,,,, 00:43  |  bernard ross 05/10/07
  311.   Correction of my error (Axel #223) 00:52  |  Tosefta 05/10/07
  312.   Re: Walid #50 00:55  |  Michael 05/10/07
  313.   Chris 00:57  |  Connie 05/10/07
  314.   Series of errors (Mark Lincoln #235; Ronnie Wolman #229) 01:07  |  Tosefta 05/10/07
  315.   Israel`s attack on Liberty--WHY? 01:29  |  Mark 05/10/07
  316.   The Liberty - Can you take the truth? 01:38  |  Neil 05/10/07
  317.   Israel won this one 01:46  |  Janice 05/10/07
  318.   Gray 01:46  |  John 05/10/07
  319.   Yes Virginia, there are Israeli war mongers. 01:55  |  Paul Eichhorn 05/10/07
  320.   Steve # 256 01:59  |  Neil 05/10/07
  321.   USS Liberty survivor YOU were spying 02:00  |  James Kevin O`Leary 05/10/07
  322.   U.S.S.LIBERTY 02:01  |  John 05/10/07
  323.   Bernard Ross 02:04  |  Connie M. 05/10/07
  324.   Murray of Montreal THE US WAS SPYING 02:08  |  GZLives 05/10/07
  325.   YES THEY ATTACKED THE LIBERTY,BUTWHY 02:09  |  MANOSHKA 05/10/07
  326.   Rodolfo - Not quite 02:12  |  Netanel 05/10/07
  327.   Egypt KILLED Israeli POWS SECOND TIME 02:14  |  GZLives 05/10/07
  328.   You are all so dumb (both sides) 02:14  |  Iceberg 05/10/07
  329.   Mark Lincoln 02:19  |  Neil 05/10/07
  330.   Attack on the Liberty 02:19  |  Ingrid Klotz 05/10/07
  331.   Axel 02:19  |  Netanel 05/10/07
  332.   Mark Lincoln 02:21  |  Yosemite 05/10/07
  333.   ofcourse they did,but why SPYING 02:21  |  GZLives 05/10/07
  334.   Insantiy from "Palestinian Prince" 02:23  |  Netanel 05/10/07
  335.   More victims of yet another Israeli "accident" 02:23  |  peacelover 05/10/07
  336.   Realism 178 02:24  |  Ron 05/10/07
  337.   U.S.S. Liberty 02:24  |  Norman Gardner 05/10/07
  338.   You are all so dumb (both sides) pt. II 02:36  |  Iceberg 05/10/07
  339.   SMUG PEACELOVER ? 03:06  |  GZLives 05/10/07
  340.   Tosefta 03:06  |  American in NY 05/10/07
  341.   WALID 272 03:25  |  JOJO 05/10/07
  342.   paranoia celebrates 03:36  |  Michael N 05/10/07
  343.   EVEN IF 03:39  |  JOJO 05/10/07
  344.   Guess what GZlives 03:39  |  John 05/10/07
  345.   Tosefta - errors 03:49  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  346.   to all haters 03:51  |  philosopher 05/10/07
  347.   Jake..Liberty had no Hebrew translators on board 03:58  |  Miriam 05/10/07
  348.   Neil - President Johnson 04:00  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  349.   JAKE..Napalm used NOT to sink the ship 04:04  |  Steve 05/10/07
  350.   Yosemite - the day after. 04:09  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  351.   GZLives - why spying? 04:18  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  352.   Chicago/Dave Pirates?? ahoy matey!! 04:28  |  Steve 05/10/07
  353.   Iceberg - nope 04:31  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  354.   Iceberg - nope #2 04:35  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  355.   To philosopher, #345 04:35  |  Rodolfo 05/10/07
  356.   Tosefta - obsevations 04:39  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  357.   Tosefta - intell weenies and fools 04:44  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  358.   #307Mark...what is OBVIOUS?? 04:45  |  Miriam 05/10/07
  359.   Tosefta - why? 04:53  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  360.   Miriam - no cigar 05:01  |  Mark Lincoln 05/10/07
  361.   #327 Netanel Florida? 05:06  |  Miriam 05/10/07
  362.   to American in NY #309 05:14  |  Dave from Chicago 05/10/07
  363.   Sloppy 05:15  |  Colin Wright 05/10/07
  364.   to American in NY #309 (continued) 05:20  |  Dave from Chicago 05/10/07
  365.   I want to be very clear on my position... 05:35  |  Dave from Chicago 05/10/07
  366.   Clear on my position (continued....) 05:43  |  Dave from Chicago 05/10/07
  367.   My position III 05:50  |  Dave from Chicago 05/10/07
  368.   Steve, pirates, shiver me timbers... 05:59  |  Dave from Chicago 05/10/07
  369.   Dave from Chicago # 365 06:02  |  American in NY 05/10/07
  370.   to Mark Lincoln #307 `What is obvious...` 06:03  |  Colin Wright 05/10/07
  371.   My position IV 06:08  |  Dave from Chicago 05/10/07
  372.   Mark Lincoln # 360 06:09  |  American in NY 05/10/07
  373.   American in NY #341, Mark Lincoln #360 06:11  |  Tosefta 05/10/07
  374.   Yosemite 06:15  |  Walid 05/10/07
  375.   Mark Lincoln 06:20  |  Dave from Chicago 05/10/07
  376.   #130, GZLives... 06:29  |  Silvienne 05/10/07
  377.   America Was Not An Israeli Ally in 1967 - France Was 06:32  |  Eli 05/10/07
  378.   Mark Lincoln - One more thing 06:46  |  Dave from Chicago 05/10/07
  379.   Not an Inch of New Information. Just Old LIes 06:57  |  nacl 05/10/07
  380.   Miriam - Here Is The WHY! 07:01  |  Eli 05/10/07
  381.   Zvi 07:32  |  Walid 05/10/07
  382.   Tosefta 07:39  |  Walid 05/10/07
  383.   Eli 07:46  |  Walid 05/10/07
  384.   American in NY 07:58  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/10/07
  385.   BETWEEN 1967 AND 2007, THE SAME PERPETRATOR 07:59  |  indrajaya 05/10/07
  386.   USS Liberty 08:05  |  Murray Aronson 05/10/07
  387.   Lies, Damn Lies, and Libel 08:22  |  SJT 05/10/07
  388.   Eli 08:22  |  Yosemite 05/10/07
  389.   Am I the only Jew 08:32  |  Thomas 05/10/07
  390.   #22 YK War 08:39  |  YoY 05/10/07
  391.   #35 Clickfool 08:47  |  No dope 05/10/07
  392.   #112 Janice 09:06  |  Need to know 05/10/07
  393.   # 299 mark 09:08  |  Axel 05/10/07
  394.   # 306 09:12  |  Axel 05/10/07
  395.   YoY 09:32  |  Walid 05/10/07
  396.   The attempts of some people, on this site, to (contd) 10:12  |  S 05/10/07
  397.   Axel 10:16  |  Wach um Rein 05/10/07
  398.   The attempts of some people, on this site, to (cont`d) 10:21  |  S 05/10/07
  399.   # 397 Wacht am Rhein (mind the spelling) 12:02  |  Axel 05/10/07
  400.   # 390 yoy 12:10  |  Axel 05/10/07
  401.   S #398 - do TB posters aim to undermine US/Israel friendship? 12:25  |  dana 05/10/07
  402.   for american elite, israeli lives are more important than the ame 12:59  |  mehmet 05/10/07
  403.   dana #401 13:08  |  S 05/10/07
  404.   # 403 s 13:37  |  Axel 05/10/07
  405.   ron 336 14:06  |  realism 05/10/07
  406.   Axel 14:15  |  American in NY 05/10/07
  407.   American in NY #341, Mark Lincoln #360 - 2nd try 15:30  |  Tosefta 05/10/07
  408.   Mark Lincoln 15:39  |  Yosemite 05/10/07
  409.