Metzger to return to key religious court position next month - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Tue., February 05, 2008 Shvat 29, 5768

Israel Time: 01:48 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Rosner's Domain

Diplomacy

Defense

Jewish World

Opinion

National

Print Edition

Advertising

Books

Arts & Leisure

Business

Real Estate

Easy Start

Travel

Week's End

Anglo File

Metzger to return to key religious court position next month

By Yuval Yoaz

Tags: Jewish law, Rabbinical Court

Chief Rabbi Yonah Metzger intends to end his voluntary suspension and return next month to his position as a member of the Supreme Rabbinical Court and as a member of the committee that appoints religious court judges even though this appointments committee is in the midst of discussions as to whether to remove Metzger from these panels.

The Ometz non-profit organization for good government organization, which is conducting a legal battle in the High Court of Justice to remove Metzger as chief rabbi, is planning on filing another petition within a week if Metzger does not change his mind.

In April 2006, Attorney General Menachem Mazuz published a report in which he called for Metzger's resignation as chief rabbi, following a criminal investigation into the rabbi's stays in Jerusalem hotels, free of charge. But at the same time, Mazuz said he would not be issuing an indictment against Metzger, even though he accused him of lying during the investigation.

	Advertisement

In reaction to this report, Metzger filed a petition against Mazuz at the High Court, and the court last year criticized the attorney general for calling for Metzger's resignation, saying he did not have the authority to do so, and recommended that he rewrite that section of his report.

But based on the rest of the report, Justice Minister Daniel Friedmann asked the rabbinical judicial appointments committee to meet to discuss Metzger's removal from this committee, and that of the Supreme Rabbinical Court.

About a month ago, the committee decided to allow Mazuz to air additional claims before it, and postponed further deliberations until the end of January; but even at last week's meeting no decision was made concerning Metzger.

"We feel there is no cause for continuing the rabbi's voluntary suspension," wrote David Libai, Metzger's attorney. "The criminal file has been closed for almost two years, there is no disciplinary procedure against the rabbi, and the attorney general also has changed his mind about calling for the rabbi's resignation. "To the best of our understanding there is no obstacle for Rabbi Metzger to return to his position as religious court judge and member of the appointments committee for religious court judges," Libai said.

Nevertheless, Libai announced in Metzger's name that he did not intend in participating in the committee's meeting which would discuss his removal.

In response to Libai's announcement, Ometz attorney Boaz Arad asked Friedman to prevent meetings of the committee if Metzger returns to serve on the committee - except for meetings to discuss his removal.

"The committee on appointments of religious judges has been unable to reach a decision for a long time, and the circumstances created a feeling for Metzger that the causes that led him to suspend himself at the time from his judicial position and participation in the committee have ended and no longer exist," Arad wrote to Friedman.

"But the return of a figure with morals such as those of Rabbi Metzger to a judicial role, and even more to a judgeship on the Supreme Rabbinical Court, is unbearable from any public perspective," he said.

Metzger's commitment to suspend himself came as a result of a petition to the High Court by Ometz to force the justice minister to take steps to remove Metzger, as recommended by Mazuz in his 2006 report.

The committee is not empowered to remove Metzger from his post as chief rabbi, but it is unlikely that he will continue to serve in this role if he is removed from his positions as a Supreme Rabbinical Court judge and judicial appointments committee member.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Prayer change
	Pope Benedict XVI nixes a reference to Jews` `blindness` over Jesus in a Catholic prayer.


	Blind and deaf in Jaffa
	'The world's first professional deaf-blind theatre company' takes center stage in Jaffa.

Today Online


	IAF strike on Hamas police headquarters in Gaza kills seven
	Responses: 184


	Burston: Barack Obama for Prime Minister of Israel
	Responses: 127


	The Israel Factor: Is Obama really pro-Palestinian?
	Responses: 63


	Foreign Min. backs Cairo request to double border forces
	Responses: 65


	Harel & Issacharoff: The 300km problem along Egyptian border
	Responses: 53


	U.K. to fund school trips of understanding to Auschwitz
	Responses: 77

More Headlines
01:22 Several hurt by Qassams in Sderot; IDF kills 9 in Gaza


01:33 Egypt warns Hamas against provocations on Gaza border


22:15 In about turn, U.S. says Iran may be able to make nukes by 2009


20:44 Pope nixes reference to Jews` `blindness` over Jesus in prayer


16:14 Haredi sect brands Chief Rabbi Metzger 'Zionist stooge,' wicked


21:43 Dimona bombing victim's son: Mom was to celebrate her 50th wedding anniversary


00:03 Jordan urges U.S. to pressure Israel to stop Gaza strikes


23:46 Former IDF chief Dan Shomron hospitalized for apparent stroke


22:29 Obama predicts split decision in Democrat race on Super Tuesday


22:19 Father, son suspected of killing man they accused of stealing dog


16:53 Two teens admit vandalizing Jewish cemetery in southern Hungary


00:45 German children's book draws fire for alleged anti-religion bent